Are Data Breach Notices Breaching Privacy?

December 16th, 2008 Rob Douglas

by Rob Douglas

Every day, several times a day, I check out PogoWasRight.org.  The site, run by an individual who goes by the alias Dissent, does a tremendous job tracking threats to privacy from around the world.

Today, Dissent has published an original piece, When Breach Notifications Breach Privacy, questioning whether those who file mandatory breach notices with various state attorney generals around the United States may, at times, be including personal information that only furthers the exposure of the breached data.

Dissent, who examined this problem earlier this year, notes:

“Back in May, I reported a situation in which a breach notification letter to a state attorney general had revealed patient information, thereby creating yet another breach that was compounded by the publication of the notification letter on the Web. Because a similar web exposure problem recently occurred, I thought I would take a moment to point out what some CPOs, CSOs, and other reporting entities may not know or think about when they write their notification letters: if you file a mandated notification to states attorney general or another state agency or department under a state’s mandated notification laws, your notification letters generally become public records that are obtainable under public records or freedom of information laws.”

After reviewing which states have central registries where breach notices are available via one method or another, Dissent conclodes this way:

“Having to disclose a breach can be embarrassing enough. Revealing someone’s personal information in your disclosure is even more embarrassing. When you include copies of your notification letters to affected individuals or other documentation concerning the breach, check to ensure that you have not included any actual individual’s information in the letter. You’ll thank me later.”

Personally, I think we all owe Dissent our gratitude now for all the great work being done over at PogoWasRight.org.

Posted in Data Breach, SSN Identity Theft, Security Breach | 1 Comment »

One Response

  1. Compare Identity Theft Protection Services Says:

    It is so unfortunate that identity theft victims are routinely re-victimized by corporations that don’t take the proper steps to rectify their breaches. I would say that this is surprising except for the fact that many of these corporate data breaches are the result of sloppy or inept security in the first place. It seems like the only way to make corporations more accountable is to find a way to hold the CEOs, CIOs, CSOs, CPOs, etc personally liable for damages in such breaches the way that Sarbanes/Oxley makes CEOs and CFOs personally liable for accounting irregularities.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.